Corporal punishment is the physical punishment by
hitting, kicking and many others. In education this punishment is given to the
student who does not obey the discipline. Nowadays most of the teachers give
the corporal punishment for the student. This punishment is not good to be
applied in education. It can cause many negatives effects; it can be explained
by the following reasons.
Corporal punishment can lower a child’s IQ. A study at
the University of New Hampshire, released in 1998, found that corporal
punishment apparently slows down their intellectual development. That is why
this punishment is not good in education. The student who has high IQ and
clever may become lower IQ and stupid student, there are too many student who
can not increased their IQ because of this punishment. It also can hamper their
creativity and imagination.
Corporal
punishment can cause serious physical damage. We can find much news in the mass
media that talk the about the student needing treatment for broken arm or
injures on their skin. In this case we can conclude that the student is not
safe with this punishment, in Washington sometimes the teacher hit or kick the
student on their sex organ. So, this case is under human right, it doesn’t
solve the problem but make new problems.
On
the other hand, Walter William said that corporal punishment is a good tool for
disciplining students. Nowadays there
are criminals done by the student in the school and out of school. This punishment
is the wider solution to solve it, the student can not prevented by speaking
and the other punishment. Corporal punishment can make the student afraid to do
the mistake, it can be more effective.
The second opponent is the
corporal punishment can help save a child’s future. Oscar Goodman said “I also believe
in a little bit of corporal punishment going back to the days of yore, where
examples have to be shown.” For example the student who gets this punishment in
the school she or he will not break the discipline but obey the discipline. The
discipline student will be the success people in the future.
In
short, corporal punishment is not good for student. Corporal punishment can
help to save child’s future and it a good tool to discipline the student. Those
are not good reasons for corporal punishment allowed to be applied in
education. There are many ways to make the student discipline. Children do not
need hitting but they need advising and motivation. The other way is by giving
them the good example in their daily.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar